The truth about retirement calculators: How reliable are they? 🧐💻
Understanding your retirement needs
Retirement planning is one of the most important financial decisions Australians over 60 need to consider. One key question: How much money do you really need to retire comfortably?
While superannuation funds are expected to assist members in calculating this, research reveals that many retirement calculators might not be as reliable as we’d like them to be.
The problem with super fund retirement calculators
A recent study by Super Consumers Australia (SCA) found that many retirement calculators across major superannuation funds provide inconsistent and potentially misleading results. The study showed that:
- 77% of calculators suggested retirement incomes that were either too high or too low.
- Some calculators didn’t account for key factors like mortgages or rent.
- Only 25 out of 50 super funds provided a retirement calculator, with just eight linking to the Australian Government’s Moneysmart tool.
These discrepancies can lead to financial miscalculations and poor retirement planning.
Why are results so different?
Many retirement calculators make assumptions about factors like:
- Life expectancy: Some suggest retirement savings should last until a person is over 100, while others plan for much shorter timeframes.
- Spending habits: Assumptions on how much retirees will need to spend each year are often arbitrary.
- Housing status: Some calculators don’t ask whether you’ll have a mortgage or be renting during retirement.
These assumptions can lead to significant differences in the retirement income estimates provided by various super funds.
What did the study find?
When testing 22 different retirement calculators for a 50-year-old woman with a median income and super balance:
- Projected retirement balances ranged from $187,251 to $260,883.
- Estimated annual retirement incomes varied by 74%, from $29,928 to $42,000 per year.
- The age at which super was projected to run out ranged from 72 to over 100.
Only one calculator—AMP’s—asked for a detailed budget to help make more accurate predictions.
What to look for in a retirement calculator
According to Super Consumers Australia, every retirement calculator should offer:
- A detailed budget to guide spending.
- Support for those retiring with a mortgage or other significant financial obligations.
- A predicted annual retirement income that reflects realistic life expectancies.
Unfortunately, most current calculators fall short of providing these essential features.
Checklist of the major funds’ retirement calculators
Proceed with caution
Danielle Bloodworth, a financial adviser at Emerald Wealth, suggests that while retirement calculators can provide a useful starting point, they should not be relied upon solely. For a more accurate picture of your retirement finances:
- Create a detailed budget, factoring in one-off expenses like travel or medical costs.
- Be conservative with your investment return assumptions to avoid falling short.
Chris Youssef, from Wealth Investors, also recommends factoring in potential lifestyle changes and healthcare costs to ensure a more comprehensive retirement plan.
Government calls for better tools
Cameron O’Sullivan, Head of Product at DASH, is among those calling for improved retirement tools. He believes that retirement calculators should:
- Include Age Pension and personal budgets.
- Offer tailored recommendations based on individual financial needs.
- Help people manage their super funds more effectively as they approach retirement.
Wrap up: A smarter approach to retirement planning
While retirement calculators can be a useful tool, they should be used with caution. It’s important to:
- Use tools like the Moneysmart retirement planner for more reliable guidance.
- Consult with a financial adviser to ensure your retirement plan is comprehensive and personalised.
Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is general advice and does not consider your specific financial situation. Please consult a qualified financial adviser before making any financial decisions regarding your retirement.
Read more articles on Superannuation and SMSF here
